Dominic Kirby outlines some of his strategies on how to teach complex or often-misunderstood concepts in History.

A few months ago I was wandering around the cloisters of Wells Cathedral in Somerset. Wells is a beautiful cathedral. Its cloisters aren’t perhaps as fine as those of Canterbury or Gloucester but they’re very impressive and majestic nonetheless.

As I was wandering around them, an old door caught my eye. At first glance it was a very typical door in a very typical setting – a heavy oak door set in a heavy stone arch. I’m no dendrochronologist but I’ve visited enough castles, cathedrals and churches in my time to know it was almost certainly late medieval or Tudor. What caught my eye about this old but otherwise unremarkable door was that it featured a very obvious anachronism – it had a modern combination lock on it. Clearly the original lock had been replaced with this new one.

I wandered on and thought no more of the door as I continued looking around the rest of the cathedral. It was only later, when I was sipping a hot chocolate in one of the pleasant little cafes in the cathedral precinct, it struck me that this door would be an excellent example to use when teaching two key concepts in History – continuity and change. Continuity, because it’s the same door in the same cathedral performing the same purpose it was installed for five or six centuries ago. Change, because a key feature of the door (pun intended) has been replaced with a new one. The door is both simultaneously the same and paradoxically different from how it was in the past.

This paradox is one reason I think learning and understanding a new concept in History can be a hard thing for children to do – and potentially an even harder one to teach. Rather than a common noun, let’s take an abstract one. Ask the next adult or informed teenager (another paradox?) you see to give you a working definition of democracy, nationalism or inflation. Most of us ‘get the concept’ of what they are, but if we’re put on the spot and asked to give a meaningful definition or explanation of one of them, let alone to analyse or evaluate it, it becomes a much harder thing to do.

Second-Order Concepts (SOCs)

History, as a discrete academic discipline, is peppered with concepts. You can’t move for them. In recent decades some of these concepts have been herded like livestock into a number of categories which are collectively called ‘disciplinary’, ‘procedural’ or, as they’re probably best known, ‘second-order’ concepts. Much has been written about second-order concepts or SOCs and, perhaps tellingly, there is no consensus or definitive list of what constitutes a SOC. That said, the following seven concepts are usually regarded as being SOCs. They are, in alphabetical order, as opposed to order of importance or usefulness:

  • Causation and consequence
  • Chronology
  • Continuity and change
  • Evidence
  • Interpretation
  • Significance
  • Similarity and difference

I think of these concepts – and describe them to my classes – as the bare bones of History. They are the skeleton upon which the flesh and then the clothes of substantive (subject) knowledge are dressed. Second-order concepts are fundamentally important because they’re the tools of the historian’s trade – the means and method of analysis, evaluation and judgement which allow us to arrive at an effective and meaningful understanding of the past.

History Sandwiches

Starting with causation and consequence, let’s take a historical event. The Spanish Armada will do as well as any. Once I’ve taught a class about the Spanish Armada, I ask them to make a ‘history sandwich’ with their newly-acquired substantive knowledge. They do this by:

  1. Identifying and explaining the causes of the Armada. That’s the first slice of bread.
  2. Identifying and explaining the dramatic events of July to September 1588. That’s the filling.
  3. Identifying and explaining the consequences (for both England and Spain) of the failure of the Armada. That’s the second slice of bread.

Disclaimer – it you’re making history sandwiches with Year 10 or below, be prepared for a prolonged and sometimes heated debate about the merits of ham and coleslaw verses cheese and tomato. And that’s before we even factor in paninis or toasties!

Following neatly on from causation and consequence, similarity and difference is a versatile SOC because it enables pupils to compare and contrast the events they’re studying with other events they’ve studied. Assuming that a child has studied the Normans in Year 7 (a reasonable assumption as most children do) most can, if prompted, draw parallels between the events of 1588 and those of 1066. How similar or different were William the Conqueror’s aims or actions to those of King Philip II’s? How similar or different were the strengths or weaknesses of each invasion force? Why did William succeed where Philip failed? This process of comparing and contrasting one historical event to another is of course in itself an act of analysis.

Chronology can be a surprisingly hard concept for a child to grasp. The National Curriculum History programme of study for key stages 1 and 2 optimistically aims that all pupils: “know and understand the history of these islands as a coherent, chronological narrative, from the earliest times to the present day”. Chance would be a fine thing. A remarkable number of children begin secondary school with an incoherent concept of chronology itself, let alone chronological narrative. I once spent ten minutes trying to help a Year 7 pupil understand why Queen Elizabeth II isn’t Queen Elizabeth I’s daughter. Their regnal numbers had completely confused her sense of chronology. Likewise, at the other end of the school, I’ve taught very able A Level pupils who have gone on to read History at Oxbridge and Russell Group universities, who hadn’t a clue where the Bronze Age sits in relation to Romano-Britain, or where Romano-Britain sits in relation to the Viking Age.

Teaching your first unobserved lesson to your ‘own’ class is like your first solo drive after passing your driving test – it’s a proud and satisfying moment that stays with you forever. My first class was 7J. The very first thing I did with them was to line them up against a wall and give them one minute to rearrange themselves into chronological order of the month they were born, with January on the far left and December on the far right. Then we did the same thing with people holding up key dates, events and people. As well as being a good way to teach or remind pupils of the concept of chronology, it’s also a good (and sometimes comical) test of initiative and teamwork.

Whatever concept you’re trying to teach to whichever year group, I think the key thing is to contextualise it in its historical context. For example, if a pupil is struggling to analyse or evaluate what daily life was like for a soldier on the Western Front during the First World War, ask them to explain five things they (the pupil) do every day e.g. brush their teeth, walk the dog etc. Now ask them to explain five things a soldier on the Western Front did every day.

Like the door in Wells Cathedral, it can unlock a whole new way of thinking.

Marking the 200th anniversary of the death of Napoleon Bonaparte Dominic Kirby wonders if Napoleon’s legacy is really something to celebrate Words by Dominic Kirby Early in the morning of Saturday 5th May 1821, in a small, damp,…

Commemorating the 80th anniversary of Britain’s finest hour Words: Dominic Kirby Late in the afternoon on Sunday 18th August 1940, Sergeant Francis ‘Frank’ Walker-Smith was flying in a Hawker Hurricane at 10,000 feet above the English Channel. Flying…

DEPUTY HEAD Sarah Wordlaw believes it’s time to reshape the curriculum The death of George Floyd has sparked a resurgence in the ferocity of the Black Lives Matter movement, lifting the veil of institutionalised racism in our society.…

The Broadway musical Hamilton has been an absolute smash hit, both in America and London’s West End. Even if one is not familiar with the historical context of the production, they may well have heard one of the…

I would be most surprised to walk into a school these days where the pupils are not aware of the film The Greatest Showman. The track This Is Me has become an anthem of self-confidence, especially for those…

Year 8 pupil: “What exactly did hanging, drawing and quartering involve?” Me: “Well, firstly the condemned man was drawn (dragged) from the place of imprisonment to the gallows where he was hanged by the neck until he was…